EnergyAustralia pays AU$750,000 after AER says four batteries failed to deliver FCAS
EnergyAustralia has paid AU$750,000 in penalties after the Australian Energy Regulator alleged that four battery storage systems it manages did not deliver frequency services they had offered into the market, Energy-Storage.News reported on 12 November.
The AER said on 11 November that it had issued 10 infringement notices to the generator and retailer over breaches at four systems in New South Wales and Victoria on several occasions in 2023 and 2024. The regulator alleges that EnergyAustralia did not ensure the batteries could fulfil the frequency control ancillary services offers it submitted to the Australian Energy Market Operator, or that they followed AEMO's dispatch instructions for those services. The AER did not name the four sites.
Frequency control ancillary services, or FCAS, keep grid frequency close to 50 hertz by adjusting supply or demand quickly when the system falls out of balance. A provider that offers them is paid to be available and must be able to respond when called.
The problems came to light after AEMO asked market participants for frequency control data following the storms that hit Victoria in February 2024. EnergyAustralia then reported the alleged breaches itself, cooperated with the investigation and repaid AEMO the money it had received for the services, the regulator said. Paying an infringement notice is not an admission of a breach; the AER can issue one when it has reasonable grounds to believe a civil penalty provision was contravened.
AER deputy chair Justin Oliver said that as batteries take a larger role, operators must understand their operating limits, make accurate offers, follow dispatch instructions and monitor their assets regularly. Providers, he said, must be ready and able to deliver or face enforcement.
It is the AER's fourth FCAS enforcement outcome since 2019 and the first against EnergyAustralia. The closest precedent is from 2022, when the Federal Court ordered Neoen's Hornsdale Power Reserve to pay AU$900,000 for failing to deliver contingency services in 2019, a failure Neoen linked to a faulty firmware upgrade. The other two cases concerned coal plants: AU$6 million ordered against two AGL subsidiaries in 2023 and AU$200,000 paid by CS Energy in 2021. Outside the National Electricity Market, Western Australia's regulator recently fined Synergy AU$1.2 million after a software error led its Kwinana battery to submit inflated offers.

Why it matters
The market pays for frequency capability as it is offered, and checks it only when data are requested. Two of the battery cases now on record trace back to software, which suggests that the operational risk for storage operators sits as much in firmware and bidding systems as in the cells themselves.