Grid Brief ENDE

Virginia regulators open hearings on NextEra's Dominion deal with a fight over the legal test

The Virginia State Corporation Commission began evidentiary hearings on NextEra Energy's proposed acquisition of Dominion Energy on 17 November, Utility Dive reported. The all-stock deal, announced in May, would create what Utility Dive calls the world's largest regulated electric utility, with a 130 GW pipeline of large loads. The first day was largely about how to read the Utility Transfers Act, which says the commission "shall be satisfied that adequate service to the public at just and reasonable rates will not be impaired or jeopardized".

For the companies, Joe Reid of McGuireWoods said the case "is simply not the one to litigate the cost of service" or whether data centres pay their fair share, and that the deal's size "does not change the requirements" of the act. Ashley Macko, deputy general counsel for the commission, said for SCC staff that the standard requires weighing short- and long-term effects on service and rates, and that calling it "a simple 'do no harm' standard is not quite right". The Southern Environmental Law Center and the Piedmont Environmental Council argued the test is broad and, in the latter's words, "100% within your judgment".

Large customers are also parties. Google's attorney said it will present testimony that the minimum demand charge approved in Dominion's 2025 rate case discourages data centres from using their right to retail choice; Dominion said the testimony is not relevant. Amazon said that, if the deal is approved, it wants Dominion to reform its large-load interconnection queue and address new capacity needs.

Virginia regulators open hearings on NextEra's Dominion deal with a fight over the legal test
Virginia regulators open hearings on NextEra's Dominion deal with a fight over the legal test — Grid Brief

Why it matters

How narrowly the commission reads one sentence of the statute decides whether data-centre costs and rates are argued in this case or left for later rate cases. The hearings are where that line gets drawn.