Grid Brief ENDE

Ninth Circuit lets California Scope 1 and 2 reporting proceed but blocks Scope 3 and SB 261

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a split decision on 9 November on California's two climate disclosure laws, Utility Dive reported on 13 November. The ruling allows some reporting under Senate Bill 253 to go ahead while finding the rest of that law's requirements, and all of Senate Bill 261, likely unconstitutional under the First Amendment.

SB 253, the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act, requires companies with more than $1 billion in revenue to report Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions, with Scope 3 to follow. SB 261, the Climate-Related Financial Risk Act, requires companies with more than $500 million in revenue to publish their climate-related financial risks and the measures they take. Both were signed in October 2023. The US Chamber of Commerce and other business groups sued to block them; a district court declined in August 2025, and the appeal followed.

The panel upheld the lower court on direct emissions. Scope 1 and 2 disclosures, it said, regulate commercial speech, factual information about a company's own operations. It reversed on Scope 3: requiring supply-chain emissions data that is insufficiently tethered to a company's own operations does not qualify as commercial speech and is likely unconstitutional. On SB 261 the majority found that the biennial reports, based on the TCFD framework, compel noncommercial speech. Judge Jacqueline Nguyen wrote that they demand value-laden judgments on a politically fraught subject, and that California could have used less restrictive means such as voluntary disclosure. SB 261 had already been paused since last November.

The timing left companies with a deadline in force. The first annual Scope 1 and 2 reports for the latest fiscal year were due to the California Air Resources Board on 10 November, the day after the ruling, and because the court did not pause that part, the deadline stood. CARB had not published a count of submissions by the time of the report.

Law firms quoted by Utility Dive read the next steps differently in detail but similarly in direction. Ropes & Gray called pausing Scope 3 work a low-risk proposition and said this year's Scope 1 and 2 compliance had effectively been a practice run, with more prescriptive requirements and limited assurance expected next year. Morrison & Foerster said SB 261 compliance is unlikely in the near future, and Crowell & Moring cautioned that the ruling supports preliminary relief rather than permanently striking down the requirements.

Ninth Circuit lets California Scope 1 and 2 reporting proceed but blocks Scope 3 and SB 261
Ninth Circuit lets California Scope 1 and 2 reporting proceed but blocks Scope 3 and SB 261 — Grid Brief

Why it matters

The line the court drew runs between what a company measures about itself and what it is asked to estimate or judge. The surviving part of SB 253 covers what companies measure about their own plants and fuel use, while the parts that would have pushed reporting along their customers' and suppliers' chains are on hold.

Written by Victoria Shinder.