Austria fines a balancing provider €150,000 after -€15,000/MWh bids cost €5 million in a day
Austria's energy regulator E-Control has fined the managing director of a balancing service provider €150,000 for manipulating the balancing energy market, the EU energy regulators' agency ACER reported on 13 November. The provider is jointly liable for the fine and must give up its gains from the manipulation, about €200,000. Neither ACER nor the summary names the company.
The case goes back to winter 2024. Austrian Power Grid (APG), the transmission system operator, awarded capacity to the prequalified provider in its tender for automatic Frequency Restoration Reserve (aFRR), the reserve operators activate to keep the system balanced. The award obliged the provider to submit energy bids for the delivery periods concerned.
According to E-Control, the provider risked being unable to deliver because the back-up measures it had presented to APG during prequalification were not available. To avoid being activated, it changed its bids for negative balancing energy, used when the grid has a surplus of electricity, to the price limit of -€15,000/MWh.
Some of those bids were activated anyway. Because the market is pay-as-cleared, with the last activated bid setting the price, they set the marginal price in several delivery periods. APG's costs for aFRR balancing energy that day came to about €5 million, which ultimately fell on network users.
E-Control concluded that the bids were non-genuine, since they were not intended to be executed, and likely to give false or misleading signals to the market; once activated, they fixed prices at an artificial level. It also found them deceptive, because they were meant to suggest the provider could meet its prequalification commitments when it could not. That amounts to market manipulation under Article 5 of REMIT.

Why it matters
A bid at the price floor is usually read as a provider's honest statement that it does not want to be called. The ruling treats it as manipulation when the provider has an obligation to be available and uses the price to hide that it cannot be. In a pay-as-cleared market the cost of one such bid is not limited to the bidder's own volume, which is how a single day reached €5 million.