Industry backs Trump's foreign grid equipment order but asks DOE to judge function, not origin
Executive Order 14421, signed on 26 August, gives US Energy Secretary Chris Wright the power to stop the installation of foreign-produced equipment on the bulk power system, along with any associated component, software, firmware, digital or maintenance service or remote-access capability, when it poses an undue risk to national security through sabotage or supply disruption. It also lets the secretary order equipment that is already installed to be removed and replaced.
The Department of Energy must publish implementing rules by 24 December, and in September it asked the industry for comment. Utility Dive's review of the responses, published on 4 November, finds broad support for the order's purpose and widespread worry about how it will be applied.
The recurring argument is that origin is the wrong test. Respondents pointed out that weaknesses in software and remote-access features can be exploited by anyone, wherever the product was made, so security requirements may matter more than country of manufacture. According to figures compiled by industry analyst Brendon Shank, most responses that took a position on that question wanted DOE to stress functional controls over origin.
Many respondents also asked for new compliance obligations to be phased in and for a way to let vendors prequalify as trustworthy. The timing is sensitive: utilities are projected to spend more than a trillion dollars on grid upgrades through 2030 and are already competing for equipment contracts, so a rule that pauses or reverses installations would land in the middle of that buildout.

What it means
The December rules will decide whether the order works as a security filter or as a supply constraint. A test based on what equipment can do and how it is controlled would reach the risk respondents describe without automatically ruling out large parts of the supply chain.