Who gets paid for reliability: PJM auction timing, HVDC lines and solar plants with batteries
Three items from the first week of November describe the same shift from different sides: the resources that keep the lights on at the hardest hour are multiplying, and the markets that pay for them are struggling to keep up.
On the market side, Exelon asked FERC on 3 November to move PJM from auctions held three years in advance to a prompt auction two months before delivery, starting in 2030/31, arguing that forecasts, resource data and accreditation are too uncertain that far out. A day later Invenergy Transmission complained that MISO counts the capacity value of merchant HVDC lines when sizing its purchases while refusing to accredit or pay them; its Grain Belt Express could provide more than 1,800 MW by one method.
On the resource side, EIA data published on 30 October show 16% of new US solar this year, about 41 GW, built with batteries, against 2% in 2017, with the share expected to pass 30% within two years. The EIA's reasoning is that a plant with a battery can hold midday energy and sell it when prices rise, which is exactly the evening hour capacity markets are designed to cover.
Put together, capacity is no longer only a property of power plants. Transmission lines that import power across regions and batteries attached to solar both supply it, and both raise the same question as Exelon's complaint: whether a market that sets prices years ahead can value assets whose contribution depends on how they are operated.
PJM is gathering reform proposals for a workshop on 13 November, with options ranging from stabilising the current design to moving towards energy and ancillary services. FERC decisions on the two complaints will show how far the regulator is willing to go in the meantime.

What it means
The debate is moving from how much capacity to buy to which assets count and when they are counted. Getting that wrong either overpays for reliability or leaves useful resources without a reason to be built.