Indiana backs AES plan for a 390 MW Google data center; all customers pay $73.8m of upgrades
The Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission has approved AES Indiana's plan to serve a Google data center near Monrovia, south-west of Indianapolis, in a contested case that Utility Dive reports in detail. Under the 7 October order, AES will build or buy generation, storage and grid assets for a 390 MW data center at an estimated project cost of about $737 million, and those assets go into the utility's rate base.
The disputed line is $73.8 million of network upgrades. Google pays about $32 million upfront for the direct connection to its site, but the network upgrades enter AES Indiana's transmission rate base and are recovered from all customers, residential ones included. The commission approved the plan 5-0, writing that although the customer may be the reason for the upgrades, that does not stop them from benefiting the whole system, and that existing customers can reasonably carry part of them just as Google will carry part of the existing network.
Consumer advocates disagree. Ben Inskeep of the Citizens Action Coalition, which intervened, says the upgrades are driven specifically by the Google project and that spreading them across other ratepayers runs against the Ratepayer Protection Pledge that Google and AES Indiana signed this year. Claire Wayner of RMI argues that if an upgrade would not have been built without the data center, the utility should show the benefit to the rest of the zone before sharing the cost.
AES's answer is that allocation and recovery are different things. A spokesperson says Google's rate contains a separate incremental-cost test meant to recover the costs of serving it, network upgrades included. AES puts Google's contribution to fixed costs at $300 million over the contract at minimum demand, covering the full annual revenue requirement of the upgrades, and about $770 million at expected demand. Much of the service agreement, including energy and demand charges, is redacted.
The physical plan is larger than the load. The portfolio pairs 460 MW of four-hour storage with 130 MW of solar, and the new substation is designed for 1,200 MW, leaving room to expand. Critics also object that Google's rates assume a 90% load factor, which they call a 10% discount.

Why it matters
Indiana law requires large customers to reimburse at least 80% of costs reasonably allocable to them, and this order shows how much room that phrase leaves. With key prices redacted, other customers cannot check the claim that Google covers its share.